awaitly vs neverthrow

Both awaitly and neverthrow provide Result types for TypeScript. This guide compares their APIs and helps you choose the right tool.

The Conceptual Difference

neverthrow gives you a way to represent success or failure. It is a data type: Result<T, E>, combinators, and explicit error values. It does not structure your app, provide dependency injection, or model effectful computation — it’s a tool for wrapping results.

awaitly gives you a way to model computations that:

• run asynchronously
• depend on an explicit environment (deps)
• may fail with a typed error
• compose predictably (workflows, steps, retries, persistence)

In other words: neverthrow wraps results; awaitly models effects. That’s the structural difference. neverthrow is ideal for local operations and clear error returns; awaitly addresses application-level composition and environment so that as your app grows, you have one coherent abstraction for async + env + errors.

Quick Comparison

Feature	awaitly	neverthrow
Result type	Result<T, E>	Result<T, E>
Async result	AsyncResult<T, E>	ResultAsync<T, E>
Method style	Functions	Methods
Retry (standalone)	tryAsyncRetry()	Not included
Result serialization	deserialize() (typed errors)	Not included
Flatten nested Results	flatten()	Not included
Workflow orchestration	Built-in	Not included
Workflow error inference from deps	Yes	No
Step IDs + events / tracing	Yes	No

When to choose which

Concern	neverthrow	awaitly
Typed errors	✅	✅
Async composition	⚠️ manual (ResultAsync, safeTry, etc.)	✅ built-in (workflows, steps)
Dependency injection	❌	✅ (deps at creation or per run)
Unified abstraction (async + env + errors)	❌	✅
Runtime / framework	❌	❌

So: neverthrow is the smallest step from plain async/await if you only want Result types. awaitly is a bigger structural step when you want one model for composition, environment, and errors — a minimal effect-style approach for TypeScript apps.

Creating Results

awaitly

import { Awaitly } from 'awaitly';

const divide = (a: number, b: number) =>
  b === 0 ? Awaitly.err('DIVIDE_BY_ZERO') : Awaitly.ok(a / b);

const result = divide(10, 2);
/*
Output:
{ ok: true, value: 5 }
*/

neverthrow

import { ok, err } from 'neverthrow';

const divide = (a: number, b: number) =>
  b === 0 ? err('DIVIDE_BY_ZERO') : ok(a / b);

const result = divide(10, 2);
/*
Output:
Result { _value: 5 }
*/

Note

Both libraries use the familiar Ok/Err pattern. neverthrow exports ok/err top-level; awaitly exports them via Awaitly.ok/Awaitly.err (and may also expose named exports from 'awaitly'). The pattern is the same; the import style differs.

Checking Results

awaitly

import { Awaitly } from 'awaitly';

const result = divide(10, 2);

// Property-based
if (result.ok) {
  console.log(result.value); // 5
}

// Function-based
if (Awaitly.isOk(result)) {
  console.log(result.value); // 5
}

neverthrow

const result = divide(10, 2);

// Method-based
if (result.isOk()) {
  console.log(result.value); // 5
}

if (result.isErr()) {
  console.log(result.error);
}

Transforming Values

map

awaitly

import { Awaitly } from 'awaitly';

const result = Awaitly.ok(5);
const doubled = Awaitly.map(result, n => n * 2);
/*
Output:
{ ok: true, value: 10 }
*/

neverthrow

import { ok } from 'neverthrow';

const result = ok(5);
const doubled = result.map(n => n * 2);
/*
Output:
Result { _value: 10 }
*/

mapError

awaitly

import { Awaitly } from 'awaitly';

const result = Awaitly.err('NOT_FOUND');
const mapped = Awaitly.mapError(result, e => ({ code: e, status: 404 }));
/*
Output:
{ ok: false, error: { code: 'NOT_FOUND', status: 404 } }
*/

neverthrow

import { err } from 'neverthrow';

const result = err('NOT_FOUND');
const mapped = result.mapErr(e => ({ code: e, status: 404 }));
/*
Output:
Result { _error: { code: 'NOT_FOUND', status: 404 } }
*/

Pipeline style (awaitly)

awaitly provides Awaitly.pipe and Awaitly.R for left-to-right composition. Awaitly.R exposes curried combinators that work inside pipe:

import { Awaitly } from 'awaitly';

const result = Awaitly.pipe(
  Awaitly.ok(5),
  Awaitly.R.map((n) => n * 2),
  Awaitly.R.mapError((e) => e.toUpperCase())
);
// { ok: true, value: 10 }

See Functional Utilities for the full set of combinators and async helpers.

Chaining Operations

andThen / flatMap

awaitly

import { Awaitly } from 'awaitly';

const parseNumber = (s: string) => {
  const n = parseInt(s, 10);
  return isNaN(n) ? Awaitly.err('PARSE_ERROR') : Awaitly.ok(n);
};

const result = Awaitly.ok('42');
const parsed = Awaitly.andThen(result, parseNumber);
/*
Output:
{ ok: true, value: 42 }
*/

neverthrow

import { ok, err } from 'neverthrow';

const parseNumber = (s: string) => {
  const n = parseInt(s, 10);
  return isNaN(n) ? err('PARSE_ERROR') : ok(n);
};

const result = ok('42');
const parsed = result.andThen(parseNumber);
/*
Output:
Result { _value: 42 }
*/

Pattern Matching

awaitly

import { Awaitly } from 'awaitly';

const result = Awaitly.ok(42);
const message = Awaitly.match(
  result,
  value => `Success: ${value}`,
  error => `Error: ${error}`
);
/*
Output:
"Success: 42"
*/

neverthrow

import { ok } from 'neverthrow';

const result = ok(42);
const message = result.match(
  value => `Success: ${value}`,
  error => `Error: ${error}`
);
/*
Output:
"Success: 42"
*/

Async Operations

awaitly

import { Awaitly, type AsyncResult } from 'awaitly';

const fetchUser = async (id: string): AsyncResult<User, 'NOT_FOUND'> => {
  const user = await db.find(id);
  return user ? Awaitly.ok(user) : Awaitly.err('NOT_FOUND');
};

// Use with regular async/await
const result = await fetchUser('123');
if (result.ok) {
  console.log(result.value.name);
}

neverthrow

import { ok, err, ResultAsync } from 'neverthrow';

const fetchUser = (id: string): ResultAsync<User, 'NOT_FOUND' | 'DB_ERROR'> =>
  ResultAsync.fromPromise(db.find(id), () => 'DB_ERROR' as const)
    .andThen((user) => (user ? ok(user) : err('NOT_FOUND' as const)));

const result = await fetchUser('123');
if (result.isOk()) {
  console.log(result.value.name);
}

Note

db.find(id) typically resolves to User | null rather than rejecting, so modelling “not found” requires an extra andThen step in neverthrow. In awaitly the typed error is returned directly.

Batch Operations

Combining Multiple Results

awaitly

import { Awaitly } from 'awaitly';

const results = [Awaitly.ok(1), Awaitly.ok(2), Awaitly.ok(3)];
const combined = Awaitly.all(results);
/*
Output:
{ ok: true, value: [1, 2, 3] }
*/

const withError = [Awaitly.ok(1), Awaitly.err('FAILED'), Awaitly.ok(3)];
const failed = Awaitly.all(withError);
/*
Output:
{ ok: false, error: 'FAILED' }
*/

neverthrow

import { ok, err, Result } from 'neverthrow';

const results = [ok(1), ok(2), ok(3)];
const combined = Result.combine(results);
/*
Output:
Result { _value: [1, 2, 3] }
*/

const withError = [ok(1), err('FAILED'), ok(3)];
const failed = Result.combine(withError);
/*
Output:
Result { _error: 'FAILED' }
*/

Unwrapping

awaitly

import { Awaitly } from 'awaitly';

const result = Awaitly.ok(42);

// Throws if err
const value1 = Awaitly.unwrap(result); // 42

// Default value (does not throw)
const value2 = Awaitly.unwrapOr(result, 0); // 42

// Computed default
const value3 = Awaitly.unwrapOrElse(result, err => {
  console.log('Failed:', err);
  return 0;
}); // 42

neverthrow

import { ok } from 'neverthrow';

const result = ok(42);

// Default value (does not throw)
const value1 = result.unwrapOr(0); // 42

// Pattern match
const value2 = result.match(
  (v) => v,
  (_e) => 0
); // 42

// In tests only (throws on Err)
const value3 = result._unsafeUnwrap(); // 42

awaitly: unwrap() throws on Err; unwrapOr/unwrapOrElse never throw. neverthrow’s throwing equivalent is _unsafeUnwrap() (intended for tests); for computed defaults use match().

Async Chaining

asyncAndThen

Chain a sync Result into an async operation.

awaitly

import { Awaitly, type AsyncResult } from 'awaitly';

const parseId = (s: string) => {
  const n = parseInt(s, 10);
  return isNaN(n) ? Awaitly.err('PARSE_ERROR') : Awaitly.ok(n);
};

const fetchUser = async (id: number): AsyncResult<User, 'NOT_FOUND'> => {
  const user = await db.find(id);
  return user ? Awaitly.ok(user) : Awaitly.err('NOT_FOUND');
};

// Just use async function - awaitly handles sync→async naturally
const result = await Awaitly.andThen(parseId('42'), fetchUser);
/*
Output:
{ ok: true, value: { id: 42, name: 'Alice' } }
*/

neverthrow

import { ok, err, ResultAsync } from 'neverthrow';

const parseId = (s: string) => {
  const n = parseInt(s, 10);
  return isNaN(n) ? err('PARSE_ERROR' as const) : ok(n);
};

const fetchUser = (id: number) =>
  ResultAsync.fromPromise(db.find(id), () => 'NOT_FOUND' as const);

// Use asyncAndThen to chain sync Result → ResultAsync
const result = await parseId('42').asyncAndThen(fetchUser);
/*
Output:
Result { _value: { id: 42, name: 'Alice' } }
*/

Note

In awaitly, andThen works with both sync and async functions. neverthrow has separate andThen (sync) and asyncAndThen (async) methods.

asyncMap

Transform the success value with an async function.

awaitly

import { Awaitly } from 'awaitly';

const result = Awaitly.ok(42);

// map works with async functions
const enriched = await Awaitly.map(result, async (n) => {
  const data = await fetchMetadata(n);
  return { value: n, metadata: data };
});
/*
Output:
{ ok: true, value: { value: 42, metadata: {...} } }
*/

neverthrow

import { ok } from 'neverthrow';

const result = ok(42);

// Use asyncMap for async transformations
const enriched = await result.asyncMap(async (n) => {
  const data = await fetchMetadata(n);
  return { value: n, metadata: data };
});
/*
Output:
Result { _value: { value: 42, metadata: {...} } }
*/

Error Recovery

orElse

Provide a fallback Result on failure.

awaitly

import { Awaitly } from 'awaitly';

const result = Awaitly.err('NOT_FOUND');
const recovered = Awaitly.orElse(result, (e) => Awaitly.ok({ fallback: true, reason: e }));
/*
Output:
{ ok: true, value: { fallback: true, reason: 'NOT_FOUND' } }
*/

// Can also return a different error
const retyped = Awaitly.orElse(result, () => Awaitly.err('FALLBACK_FAILED'));
/*
Output:
{ ok: false, error: 'FALLBACK_FAILED' }
*/

neverthrow

import { err, ok } from 'neverthrow';

const result = err('NOT_FOUND');
const recovered = result.orElse((e) => ok({ fallback: true, reason: e }));
/*
Output:
Result { _value: { fallback: true, reason: 'NOT_FOUND' } }
*/

// Can also return a different error
const retyped = result.orElse(() => err('FALLBACK_FAILED'));
/*
Output:
Result { _error: 'FALLBACK_FAILED' }
*/

Collecting All Errors

combineWithAllErrors

Collect ALL errors instead of failing on the first one.

awaitly

import { Awaitly } from 'awaitly';

const results = [Awaitly.ok(1), Awaitly.err('ERROR_A'), Awaitly.ok(3), Awaitly.err('ERROR_B')];
const settled = Awaitly.allSettled(results);
// Returns a Result with collected errors (and, depending on API, may include successes/failures).
// See [Awaitly.allSettled](/reference/api/) for the exact return shape.

// For fail-fast behavior, use all() instead
const failFast = Awaitly.all(results);
/*
Output:
{ ok: false, error: 'ERROR_A' }
*/

neverthrow

import { ok, err, Result } from 'neverthrow';

const results = [ok(1), err('ERROR_A'), ok(3), err('ERROR_B')];
const combined = Result.combineWithAllErrors(results);
/*
Output:
Result { _error: ['ERROR_A', 'ERROR_B'] }
*/

// For fail-fast behavior, use combine() instead
const failFast = Result.combine(results);
/*
Output:
Result { _error: 'ERROR_A' }
*/

Note

awaitly can collect all errors; see Awaitly.allSettled (or the functional allSettled / allSettledAsync entry points) for the exact return shape.

Wrapping Throwing Functions

fromThrowable / from / fromPromise

Safely wrap functions that might throw exceptions.

awaitly

import { Awaitly } from 'awaitly';

// Sync: Awaitly.from(fn, onError)
const parseJson = (s: string) =>
  Awaitly.from(
    () => JSON.parse(s),
    (e) => ({ type: 'PARSE_ERROR' as const, message: String(e) })
  );

// Async (outside workflows): Awaitly.fromPromise(promise, onError)
const fetchSafe = (url: string) =>
  Awaitly.fromPromise(fetch(url).then(r => r.json()), () => 'FETCH_ERROR' as const);

// Inside workflows: step.try('id', () => …, { error: 'MY_ERROR' })

const valid = parseJson('{"name": "Alice"}');
const invalid = parseJson('not json');

neverthrow

import { Result, ResultAsync } from 'neverthrow';

// Sync: Result.fromThrowable(fn, onError)
const safeJsonParse = Result.fromThrowable(
  JSON.parse,
  (e) => ({ type: 'PARSE_ERROR' as const, message: String(e) })
);

// Async: ResultAsync.fromPromise(promise, onError)
const fetchSafe = (url: string) =>
  ResultAsync.fromPromise(fetch(url).then(r => r.json()), () => 'FETCH_ERROR' as const);

const valid = safeJsonParse('{"name": "Alice"}');
const invalid = safeJsonParse('not json');

Note

awaitly: Awaitly.from() runs immediately and returns a Result; Awaitly.fromPromise() for existing Promises. Inside a workflow callback you can wrap throwing code with step.try('id', () => …, { error }) so failures become typed errors. neverthrow: Result.fromThrowable returns a wrapped function; ResultAsync.fromPromise for Promises.

Generator-Based Composition

safeTry / Generators

neverthrow provides safeTry for generator-based composition. awaitly uses standard async/await instead.

awaitly (run)

import { run } from 'awaitly/run';
import { type ErrorsOf } from 'awaitly';

// awaitly uses familiar async/await — no generators needed
const deps = { parseId, fetchUser, sendEmail };
type Errors = ErrorsOf<typeof deps>;

const result = await run<User, Errors>(async ({ step }) => {
  const id = await step('parseId', () => parseId('42'));
  const user = await step('fetchUser', () => fetchUser(id));
  await step('sendEmail', () => sendEmail(user.email));
  return user;
});

// Errors short-circuit automatically, no special syntax required

awaitly (workflow)

import { createWorkflow } from 'awaitly/workflow';

// createWorkflow infers errors automatically — no ErrorsOf needed
const workflow = createWorkflow('workflow', { parseId, fetchUser, sendEmail });

const result = await workflow.run(async ({ step, deps }) => {
  const id = await step('parseId', () => deps.parseId('42'));
  const user = await step('fetchUser', () => deps.fetchUser(id));
  await step('sendEmail', () => deps.sendEmail(user.email));
  return user;
});

neverthrow

import { safeTry, ok } from 'neverthrow';

// parseId, fetchUser, sendEmail must return Result or ResultAsync for safeTry
const result = safeTry(function* () {
  const id = yield* parseId('42');      // yield* the Result directly
  const user = yield* fetchUser(id);     // Result or ResultAsync supported
  yield* sendEmail(user.email);
  return ok(user);
});

Why async/await?

Both approaches give imperative short-circuiting. The difference is what comes with it:

• neverthrow safeTry — generators give short-circuiting without a workflow engine
• awaitly workflows — async/await gives short-circuiting plus step IDs, retry/timeout/cache, and inferred error types

The “generators vs async/await” syntax is not the main differentiator — the workflow engine is.

What awaitly Adds: Workflow Orchestration

awaitly's Key Advantage

neverthrow focuses purely on Result types. awaitly adds workflow orchestration and automatic error inference — but the point isn’t “Result plus DI.” It’s a single computation model: one abstraction for async, environment, and typed failure that composes predictably.

Automatic Error Type Inference

With run(), group your deps and use ErrorsOf to derive the error union:

import { type AsyncResult, type ErrorsOf } from 'awaitly';
import { run } from 'awaitly/run';

const fetchUser = async (id: string): AsyncResult<User, 'NOT_FOUND'> => { /* ... */ };
const sendEmail = async (to: string): AsyncResult<void, 'EMAIL_FAILED'> => { /* ... */ };
const chargeCard = async (amount: number): AsyncResult<Receipt, 'PAYMENT_DECLINED'> => { /* ... */ };

const deps = { fetchUser, sendEmail, chargeCard };
type Errors = ErrorsOf<typeof deps>;

const result = await run<User, Errors>(async ({ step }) => {
  const user = await step('fetchUser', () => fetchUser('123'));
  await step('chargeCard', () => chargeCard(99.99));
  await step('sendEmail', () => sendEmail(user.email));
  return user;
});

// result.error is: 'NOT_FOUND' | 'EMAIL_FAILED' | 'PAYMENT_DECLINED' | UnexpectedError

With createWorkflow, error inference is automatic — no ErrorsOf needed:

import { createWorkflow } from 'awaitly/workflow';

const workflow = createWorkflow('workflow', { fetchUser, sendEmail, chargeCard });

const result = await workflow.run(async ({ step, deps }) => {
  const user = await step('fetchUser', () => deps.fetchUser('123'));
  await step('chargeCard', () => deps.chargeCard(99.99));
  await step('sendEmail', () => deps.sendEmail(user.email));
  return user;
});

// Same error type, automatically inferred from dependencies

Step helpers

Inside workflows, step is the workhorse. Chaining is just calling step again with the success value. Pattern matching is plain JS branching after the step returns.

const result = await workflow.run(async ({ step, deps }) => {
  const user = await step('fetchUser', () => deps.fetchUser('123'));
  const enriched = await step('enrich', () => deps.enrichUser(user));
  return enriched.displayName;
});

Built-in Retry and Timeout

const result = await workflow.run(async ({ step, deps }) => {
  // Retry with exponential backoff
  const user = await step.retry(
    'fetchUser',
    () => deps.fetchUser('123'),
    { attempts: 3, backoff: 'exponential', initialDelay: 100 }
  );

  // Timeout protection
  const data = await step.withTimeout(
    'slowOp',
    () => deps.slowOperation(),
    { ms: 5000 }
  );

  return { user, data };
});

Step Caching and Resume

// Option 1: In-memory (simple)
const workflow = createWorkflow('workflow', deps, {
  cache: new Map(),
  resumeState: savedState, // Resume from previous run
});

// Option 2: Store (awaitly-mongo or awaitly-postgres) — runWithState + save/loadResumeState
import { mongo } from 'awaitly-mongo';
// or: import { postgres } from 'awaitly-postgres';

const store = mongo(process.env.MONGODB_URI!);

const { result, resumeState } = await workflow.runWithState(async ({ step, deps }) => {
  const user = await step('fetchUser', () => deps.fetchUser('1'), { key: 'user:1' });
  return user;
});
await store.save('wf-1', resumeState);

// Restore
const loaded = await store.loadResumeState('wf-1');
if (loaded) {
  await workflow.run(async ({ step, deps }) => { /* same fn */ }, { resumeState: loaded });
}

When to Choose Each

Choose awaitly when:

• You want Result types with familiar async/await syntax
• You need workflow orchestration (retries, timeouts, caching)
• You want automatic error type inference
• You’re building multi-step async operations
• You need step-level resilience patterns
• You want to keep async/await ergonomics for multi-step flows

Choose neverthrow when:

• You only need Result types without workflow features
• You prefer method chaining over function calls
• You want the smallest possible bundle size
• Your project already uses neverthrow

Bottom line: neverthrow helps you return errors; awaitly helps you structure applications.

Method Chaining vs Functions

// neverthrow: method chaining
import { ok } from 'neverthrow';
const result = ok(5).map(n => n * 2).mapErr(e => e.toUpperCase());

// awaitly: standalone functions (no special helpers required)
import { Awaitly } from 'awaitly';

const base = Awaitly.ok(5);
const doubled = Awaitly.map(base, (n) => n * 2);
const result = Awaitly.mapError(doubled, (e) => e.toUpperCase());

For pipeline style, use Awaitly.pipe and Awaitly.R as shown in Pipeline style (awaitly) above, or a small pipe helper of your own to compose Awaitly.map / Awaitly.mapError.

Note

awaitly uses standalone functions instead of methods. This works well with tree-shaking and makes the control flow explicit. Pipeline style is supported via Awaitly.pipe and Awaitly.R (demonstrated above) and documented in Functional Utilities.

Next Steps

• Learn about Workflows →
• See the full API Reference →